Black Oak on Fifth

Name: Black Oak on Fifth
Address: 200 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11217
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

Park Slope · Italian

200 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11217Directions

4.6301 reviews

Diners like this restaurant's delicious brick-oven pizzas, flavorful pasta dishes, and hearty American comfort food, with many highlighting the excellent cocktails and drinks. They also mention the warm, stylish, and cozy atmosphere, making it a great spot for a relaxed meal. Guests appreciate the attentive, friendly, and welcoming staff, as well as the reasonable prices for the quality.

Weekend-busy Italian, backed by 2,130 Blackbird check-ins.

Black Oak on Fifth is a $$ Italian restaurant in Park Slope, Brooklyn. It has logged 2,952 check ins on Blackbird, and is busiest Thursday evenings. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

blackoakonfifth.com

The experience

Casual dining for Italian wood-fired pizza, pasta, and small plates, plus craft cocktails.

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

Why go

Black Oak on Fifth is a $$ Italian restaurant with measurable pull: 2,952 all-time Blackbird check-ins, with Saturday and Sunday standing out as its busiest days. On Google, it holds a 4.5 rating across 337 reviews, a sturdy signal of diner satisfaction.

The review trail points to a charming, historic-feeling spot with both indoor and outdoor seating, attentive service, and portions that land in the sweet spot. Diners call out light eggplant parmesan, traditional tiramisu, a calzone dessert, fried burrata, and a short rib tagliatelle praised as a standout pasta dish.

It also reads as a pre-event choice: one reviewer picked it before a Liberty game at Barclays and called it a great choice. Add in a noted wine and cocktail selection, plus a server willing to make a non-alcoholic Aperol spritz-style mocktail, and Black Oak on Fifth looks like an Italian crowd-pleaser with real repeat-visit energy.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Fast facts

Blackbird has recorded 2,952 all-time check-ins here.
Saturday and Sunday are its busiest Blackbird check-in days.
Google users rate it 4.5 from 337 reviews.
A reviewer mentions both indoor and outdoor seating.
The price level is listed as $$.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Did you know

Black Oak on Fifth has logged 2,952 Blackbird check-ins, with weekends leading the charge.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Amenities

Meals

BreakfastBrunchLunchDinnerDessert

Drinks

CoffeeBeerWineCocktails

Features

Dine-inTakeoutDeliveryReservationsOutdoor seatingRestroomGood for kidsGood for groups

Dietary

Vegetarian

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity169

check ins · last 30 days · active todaycheck ins · last 30 daysactive today

Flynet check ins

2,952

Neighborhood

Park Slope

Last 30 days

169 check ins

−53% vs prior month

Sep 28Oct 27

When it's busy

Usually dead right now

Tuesdaytoday

12a12p11p

Inside Black Oak on Fifth

The experience

Casual dining for Italian wood-fired pizza, pasta, and small plates, plus craft cocktails.

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

Review signal

4.6

301 Google reviews

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

LOCAL HOTSPOTS

What’s hot around Black Oak on Fifth

Live check in momentum from nearby Flynet restaurants.

Brooklyn

Today

75 check ins

54 check ins

33 check ins

29 check ins

21 check ins

All-time

73,910 check ins

67,910 check ins

33,296 check ins

27,123 check ins

25,583 check ins

NEARBY

Within walking distance

Other Blackbird spots a short walk from Black Oak on Fifth.

FAQ

How popular is Black Oak on Fifth?

Black Oak on Fifth has logged 2,952 check ins on Blackbird.

When is Black Oak on Fifth busiest?

Black Oak on Fifth is busiest on Thursday evenings, based on Blackbird check-in activity.

What kind of food does Black Oak on Fifth serve?

Black Oak on Fifth serves Italian cuisine.

How expensive is Black Oak on Fifth?

Black Oak on Fifth is in the $$ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

How do I check in at Black Oak on Fifth?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Black Oak on Fifth in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.