Wizard Hat Pizza

Name: Wizard Hat Pizza
Address: 539 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11225
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.8

Prospect Lefferts Gardens · Pizza

539 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11225Directions

4.8133 reviews

Covert storefront pizza with pepperoni heat and serious crust credibility.

Wizard Hat Pizza is a $$ Pizza restaurant in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Brooklyn. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

hidden gem

“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”

instagram.com

Why go

Wizard Hat Pizza is a $$ pizza operation with the kind of review trail that makes people speak in conspiratorial tones: a 4.8 Google rating across 133 reviews, plus praise for a nondescript pickup setup that feels more like a covert mission than a standard slice run. Blackbird’s on-chain footprint is still early — 9 all-time check-ins between April 18 and June 23, 2024 — with Sunday and Friday showing as the busiest days.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Fast facts

Google reviewers rate it 4.8 from 133 reviews.
Blackbird has recorded 9 all-time check-ins.
Sunday and Friday are its busiest Blackbird check-in days.
Reviewers specifically praise the cheese pie, pepperoni, pan pizza, and buttermilk ranch.
One review calls the pickup setup a “covert operation.”

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Did you know

Blackbird’s early signal is small but precise: 9 check-ins, with Sunday and Friday the busiest days.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

What people say

From real reviews

“amazing and underrated pizza”
“pizza in New”
“pizza in New York”
“menu Thank”
“menu Thank you”
“menu Thank you Wizard”
“Delicious pizza”
“Delicious pizza being”

Love the business model, it’s like a covert operation, just go to the nondescript storefront that you would walk past without noticing anything extraordinary is happening and pick up the most amazing and underrated pizza in New York. We got the cheese pie and pepperoni. Both…

Justin Lui2 years ago

Delicious pizza being cooked out of this spot. Would put it up there with some of the best in the city. Not #1 but close to it. The pan pizza was a surprisingly better hit in my opinion. Loved the breads texture. Easy system of ordering online and pizza is ready at the exact t…

Minhal2 years ago

The pizza was absolutely delicious! I really enjoyed the spiciness that came along with the pepperoni pizza, as well as the softness of the crust (cause pizza places often overcook the crust). The only two areas where I have feedback would be, for a pizza that’s already $32, I…

Duchess McIntosh2 years ago

Google reviews/ updated 10d ago

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity

Quiet lately · No check ins in the last 30 days

Flynet check ins

Neighborhood

Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Inside Wizard Hat Pizza

Review signal

4.8

133 Google reviews

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

LOCAL HOTSPOTS

What’s hot around Wizard Hat Pizza

Live check in momentum from nearby Flynet restaurants.

Brooklyn

Today

75 check ins

58 check ins

33 check ins

31 check ins

21 check ins

All-time

73,910 check ins

67,910 check ins

33,296 check ins

27,123 check ins

25,583 check ins

FAQ

What kind of food does Wizard Hat Pizza serve?

Wizard Hat Pizza serves Pizza cuisine.

How expensive is Wizard Hat Pizza?

Wizard Hat Pizza is in the $$ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

Where is Wizard Hat Pizza located?

Wizard Hat Pizza is located at 539 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11225.

How do I check in at Wizard Hat Pizza?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Wizard Hat Pizza in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.

More hotspots on Flytown