№1
Have a spot?

© 2026 Leftway

AboutPrivacyRSS
© Mapbox·© OpenStreetMap

Wizard Hat Pizza

Prospect Lefferts Gardens · Pizza

539 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11225Directions
4.8★★★★★★★★★★133 reviews

Covert-operation pizza with praised crust and pepperoni heat.

Wizard Hat Pizza is a $$ Pizza restaurant in Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Brooklyn. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

hidden gemfoodies
“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”
“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”
“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”“amazing and underrated pizza” · “pizza in New” · “pizza in New York” · “menu Thank” · “menu Thank you” · “menu Thank you Wizard”
instagram.com

Why go

Wizard Hat Pizza is a $$ pizza spot with a strong Google profile: 4.8 stars across 133 reviews. Highlighted reviews describe a low-key setup, including a nondescript storefront and an online ordering system that has pies ready at the booked time.

On the plate, the praise includes depth of flavor in the cheese pie and pepperoni, a pepperoni pizza with spice, and a crust that stays soft rather than overcooked. One reviewer called the pan pizza the surprise hit for its bread texture, while another noted add-ons like mushrooms and Buttermilk Ranch can push the bill.

Blackbird’s on-chain footprint is still small but legible: 9 all-time check-ins between April 18 and June 23, 2024, with Sunday and Friday leading the action. Translation: this is more cult signal than mass-market stampede.

editorial/ updated 22d ago

Fast facts

  • Google diners rate Wizard Hat Pizza 4.8 from 133 reviews.
  • Blackbird has recorded 9 all-time on-chain check-ins here.
  • Sunday and Friday are its busiest Blackbird check-in days.
  • Highlighted reviews call out the pepperoni, cheese pie, and pan pizza.
  • One review praises the online ordering system for exact pickup timing.
editorial/ updated 22d ago

Did you know

Its Blackbird check-ins cluster on Sunday and Friday, despite only 9 all-time recorded visits.

editorial/ updated 22d ago

What people say

What people say

From real reviews
  • “amazing and underrated pizza”
  • “pizza in New”
  • “pizza in New York”
  • “menu Thank”
  • “menu Thank you”
  • “menu Thank you Wizard”
  • “Delicious pizza”
  • “Delicious pizza being”
Love the business model, it’s like a covert operation, just go to the nondescript storefront that you would walk past without noticing anything extraordinary is happening and pick up the most amazing and underrated pizza in New York. We got the cheese pie and pepperoni. Both…
Justin Lui2 years ago
Delicious pizza being cooked out of this spot. Would put it up there with some of the best in the city. Not #1 but close to it. The pan pizza was a surprisingly better hit in my opinion. Loved the breads texture. Easy system of ordering online and pizza is ready at the exact t…
Minhal2 years ago
The pizza was absolutely delicious! I really enjoyed the spiciness that came along with the pepperoni pizza, as well as the softness of the crust (cause pizza places often overcook the crust). The only two areas where I have feedback would be, for a pizza that’s already $32, I…
Duchess McIntosh2 years ago
Google reviews/ updated 22d ago

No check in signal yet — activity shows up here once people start checking in on Blackbird.

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity
Quiet lately · No check ins in the last 30 days

Flynet check ins

9

Neighborhood

Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Inside Wizard Hat Pizza

Review signal

4.8

133 Google reviews

Google Places/ updated 22d ago

Guide

Inside Wizard Hat Pizza

Why go

Wizard Hat Pizza is a $$ pizza spot with a strong Google profile: 4.8 stars across 133 reviews. Highlighted reviews describe a low-key setup, including a nondescript storefront and an online ordering system that has pies ready at the booked time.

On the plate, the praise includes depth of flavor in the cheese pie and pepperoni, a pepperoni pizza with spice, and a crust that stays soft rather than overcooked. One reviewer called the pan pizza the surprise hit for its bread texture, while another noted add-ons like mushrooms and Buttermilk Ranch can push the bill.

Blackbird’s on-chain footprint is still small but legible: 9 all-time check-ins between April 18 and June 23, 2024, with Sunday and Friday leading the action. Translation: this is more cult signal than mass-market stampede.

editorial/ updated 22d ago

Review signal

4.8

133 Google reviews

Google Places/ updated 22d ago

What to order

editorial/ updated 22d ago

What people say

What people say

From real reviews
  • “amazing and underrated pizza”
  • “pizza in New”
  • “pizza in New York”
  • “menu Thank”
  • “menu Thank you”
  • “menu Thank you Wizard”
  • “Delicious pizza”
  • “Delicious pizza being”
Love the business model, it’s like a covert operation, just go to the nondescript storefront that you would walk past without noticing anything extraordinary is happening and pick up the most amazing and underrated pizza in New York. We got the cheese pie and pepperoni. Both…
Justin Lui2 years ago
Delicious pizza being cooked out of this spot. Would put it up there with some of the best in the city. Not #1 but close to it. The pan pizza was a surprisingly better hit in my opinion. Loved the breads texture. Easy system of ordering online and pizza is ready at the exact t…
Minhal2 years ago
The pizza was absolutely delicious! I really enjoyed the spiciness that came along with the pepperoni pizza, as well as the softness of the crust (cause pizza places often overcook the crust). The only two areas where I have feedback would be, for a pizza that’s already $32, I…
Duchess McIntosh2 years ago
Google reviews/ updated 22d ago

Fast facts

  • Google diners rate Wizard Hat Pizza 4.8 from 133 reviews.
  • Blackbird has recorded 9 all-time on-chain check-ins here.
  • Sunday and Friday are its busiest Blackbird check-in days.
  • Highlighted reviews call out the pepperoni, cheese pie, and pan pizza.
  • One review praises the online ordering system for exact pickup timing.
editorial/ updated 22d ago

Did you know

Its Blackbird check-ins cluster on Sunday and Friday, despite only 9 all-time recorded visits.

editorial/ updated 22d ago
LOCAL HOTSPOTS

What’s hot around Wizard Hat Pizza

Live check in momentum from nearby Flynet restaurants.

Brooklyn

Today

№2
0
Tacombi
Tacombi

98 check ins

№4
0
Maman
Maman

77 check ins

№28
0
Fish Cheeks
Fish Cheeks

37 check ins

№61
0
MáLà Project
MáLà Project

27 check ins

№69
0
Talea
Talea

26 check ins

All-time

№2
0
Tacombi
Tacombi

72,294 check ins

№3
0
Maman
Maman

66,580 check ins

№15
0
Fish Cheeks
Fish Cheeks

32,696 check ins

№27
0
Butcher's Daughter
Butcher's Daughter

26,635 check ins

№33
0
Roberta's
Roberta's

25,197 check ins

See all Hotspots

FAQ

What kind of food does Wizard Hat Pizza serve?

Wizard Hat Pizza serves Pizza cuisine.

How expensive is Wizard Hat Pizza?

Wizard Hat Pizza is in the $$ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

Where is Wizard Hat Pizza located?

Wizard Hat Pizza is located at 539 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11225.

How do I check in at Wizard Hat Pizza?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Wizard Hat Pizza in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.

More hotspots on Flytown

№1
0
Huriyali
Huriyali
127ins
№2
0
Tacombi
Tacombi
98ins
№3
0
Black Seed Bagels
Black Seed Bagels
91ins
№4
0
Maman
Maman
77ins
№5
0
Devoción
Devoción
76ins
№6
0
The Daily
The Daily
63ins
See all Hotspots