That’s Amore is a $$ Italian restaurant with strong repeat-visit signals: a 4.6 Google rating across 3,703 reviews and 2,374 all-time Blackbird check-ins. On Blackbird, its busiest days are Thursday and Sunday.
The review trail points to classic Italian comfort: carbonara called “to die for,” fruti di mare praised as authentic and delicious, plus pizza and pasta that bring diners back. Service is part of the draw, too, with reviewers calling the staff polite, attentive, professional, friendly, and fast.
The strongest through-line is familiarity. One reviewer says they have been coming for six years and are greeted like family; another says they eat here every time they come to NY.