Rose Pizzeria is a budget-friendly pizza and Italian spot with a 4.0 Google rating across 1,054 reviews. Highlighted reviews frame it as a Penn Station-area slice stop built for warmth and the practical ease of grabbing pizza without making a production of it.
Highlighted reviews call out fresh, warm food and nice, prideful service, especially for commuters moving fast. The caveat is also specific: one reviewer found the fresh slice great but the reheated slice only okay, so timing can matter here.
A highlighted review gives the Sicilian the strongest named praise, describing it as “special” and unlike other places. Expect a straightforward, commuter-friendly pizzeria atmosphere rather than a hushed dining room; one review also notes loud music.