Old Gold Tomato Pie is a $$ pizza spot with serious traction: 1,560 all-time Blackbird on-chain check-ins and a 4.7 Google rating from 82 reviews. Highlighted reviews praise delicious pizza, including square, focaccia-style slices with a light bite, crisp bottom, and big flavor.
This is not a sprawling dining room production. Reviewers describe a small, cozy setup with limited seating and friendly service. One highlighted review says a lunch special with two pizza slices and a canned soda was under $20. The smart play is to treat it like a high-value slice stop: quick, casual, and reasonably priced.
Blackbird data says Sunday and Thursday are the busiest check-in days, which tracks with the Sunday lunch praise in the reviews. Go expecting crisp-edged slices, a practical price point, and limited seating.