NYC Members' Nights is listed as fine dining at a $$ price point, and its Google profile is unusually strong: 4.9 stars from 92 reviews. The clearest through-line in the reviews is hospitality—staff described as friendly, accommodating, and tightly on top of group service.
The room reads less like a standard restaurant and more like a hybrid: reviewers call it a mix of restaurant, fashion store, lounge, retail shop, full bar, and food destination. It appears especially useful for hosted occasions, from a 30th birthday with a personalized cocktail menu to a company happy hour fueled by drinks, appetizers, pita/hummus, and fries.