Nick & Toni's

Name: Nick & Toni's
Address: 136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.4

East Hampton · Italian

136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY, 11937Directions

4.4376 reviews

Diners like this restaurant's delicious food, especially the homemade pasta, short rib ravioli, and zucchini fritti, as well as the excellent cocktails. They also highlight the warm, lively ambiance and the attentive, knowledgeable staff who provide great recommendations. Some reviews mention the management can be unhelpful.

Italian $$$$ with weekend Blackbird activity and dessert praise.

Nick & Toni's is a $$ Italian restaurant in East Hampton, East Hampton. It has logged 9,394 check ins on Blackbird, and is busiest Saturday late nights. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

date nightneighborhood gemspecial occasionregularsfoodiescelebrations

nickandtonis.com

The experience

The dedicated service, with staff like Jessy and Moses, who steer you towards solid choices. You get the sense they know what they're doing here.

Google Places/ updated 111d ago

Why go

Nick & Toni's holds a 4.4 rating from 376 Google reviews. Blackbird data logs 9,394 check-ins since May 2025, with Saturday and Sunday driving the bulk of traffic. This Italian spot in East Hampton executes reliably—attentive service, dishes that land, desserts that linger. Short rib ravioli, zucchini fritti, olive oil cake, strawberry sorbet made with Harris's California fruit. The kind of place people return to.

Google Places/ updated 111d ago

Fast facts

Nick & Toni’s has 9,394 all-time Blackbird check-ins.
Saturday and Sunday are its busiest Blackbird check-in days.
Google reviewers rate it 4.4 from 399 reviews.
Highlighted Google reviews call out attentive service, homemade pasta, and standout desserts.
One reviewer singled out strawberry sorbet made with Harris’s strawberries from California.

editorial/ updated today

Did you know

Nick & Toni’s has logged 9,394 Blackbird check-ins, with weekends driving the heaviest action.

editorial/ updated today

Good to know

Staff excel at recommendations. Ask them.

Google Places/ updated 111d ago

Amenities

Meals

DinnerDessert

Drinks

CoffeeBeerWineCocktails

Features

Dine-inTakeoutReservationsOutdoor seatingRestroomGood for groups

Dietary

Vegetarian

Google Places/ updated today

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity453

check ins · last 30 days · active todaycheck ins · last 30 daysactive today

Flynet check ins

9,394

Neighborhood

East Hampton

Neighborhood standing

How it ranks nearby

Most visited

№2

of 7 East Hampton spots this month

vs neighborhood median

2.6× the East Hampton median

Based on this month's Blackbird check ins across 7 East Hampton spots.

Last 30 days

453 check ins

−29% vs prior month

Sep 19Oct 18

When it's busy

Usually not too busy right now

Sundaytoday

12a12p11p

Inside Nick & Toni's

The experience

The dedicated service, with staff like Jessy and Moses, who steer you towards solid choices. You get the sense they know what they're doing here.

Google Places/ updated 111d ago

Review signal

4.4

376 Google reviews

$$$

Google Places/ updated today

LOCAL HOTSPOTS

What’s hot around Nick & Toni's

Live check in momentum from nearby Flynet restaurants.

East Hampton

Today

№58

Carissa's Bakery

4 check ins

All-time

№99

Carissa's Bakery

13,824 check ins

East Hampton

Today

№58

Carissa's Bakery

4 check ins

All-time

№99

Carissa's Bakery

13,824 check ins

See all Hotspots

NEARBY

Within walking distance

Other Blackbird spots a short walk from Nick & Toni's.

FAQ

How popular is Nick & Toni's?

Nick & Toni's has logged 9,394 check ins on Blackbird.

When is Nick & Toni's busiest?

Nick & Toni's is busiest on Saturday late nights, based on Blackbird check-in activity.

What kind of food does Nick & Toni's serve?

Nick & Toni's serves Italian cuisine.

How expensive is Nick & Toni's?

Nick & Toni's is in the $$ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

How do I check in at Nick & Toni's?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Nick & Toni's in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.