Gage & Tollner

Name: Gage & Tollner
Address: 372 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11201
Price range: $$$$
Rating: 4.3

Downtown Brooklyn · American

372 Fulton Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11201Directions

4.31,359 reviews

Diners praise this restaurant's delicious steaks, fresh oysters, and standout desserts, including the Baked Alaska and Brooklyn Blackout Cake, noting the generous portions. The stunning historic atmosphere and friendly staff contribute to the excellent service. Some reviews mention the food can be overpriced.

Old-school American steakhouse atmosphere, weekend Blackbird activity, and a hash brown one reviewer remembered.

Gage & Tollner is a $$$$ American restaurant in Downtown Brooklyn, Brooklyn. It has logged 6,823 check ins on Blackbird, and is busiest Sunday evenings. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

date nightspecial occasionsee and be seencelebrationsfoodiesregulars

gageandtollner.com

The experience

The restored room itself commands attention—a space that reads as occasion. The kind of place worth visiting more than once.

Google Places/ updated 119d ago

Why go

Gage & Tollner logs consistent traffic: over 6,823 Blackbird check-ins since November 2025, with Saturdays and Sundays as peak days. Rated 4.3 stars across 1,359 Google reviews, the steakhouse trades on both its atmosphere and execution. Service tracks as attentive. The bone-in rib and deviled on horseback (bacon-wrapped dates, cheese, almond) merit attention.

Google Places/ updated 119d ago

Fast facts

Gage & Tollner has 6,823 all-time Blackbird check-ins.
Its busiest Blackbird check-in days are Sunday and Saturday.
Google users rate it 4.3 from 1,408 reviews.
A highlighted reviewer specifically praised the brunch, cocktail program, and old-school service.
A highlighted birthday-dinner reviewer singled out the hash brown side as possibly the best potato dish they had ever had.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Did you know

Gage & Tollner’s Blackbird traffic peaks on weekends, with Sunday and Saturday leading all check-in days.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Good to know

Four-dollar pricing. Plan accordingly.
Weekend traffic is substantial.
Reserve ahead.

Google Places/ updated 119d ago

Amenities

Meals

BrunchLunchDinnerDessert

Drinks

CoffeeBeerWineCocktails

Features

Dine-inTakeoutDeliveryReservationsRestroomGood for kidsGood for groups

Dietary

Vegetarian

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity450

check ins · last 30 days · active todaycheck ins · last 30 daysactive today

Flynet check ins

6,823

Neighborhood

Downtown Brooklyn

Last 30 days

450 check ins

−19% vs prior month

Sep 28Oct 27

When it's busy

Usually dead right now

Tuesdaytoday

12a12p11p

Inside Gage & Tollner

The experience

The restored room itself commands attention—a space that reads as occasion. The kind of place worth visiting more than once.

Google Places/ updated 119d ago

Review signal

4.3

1,359 Google reviews

$$$$

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

LOCAL HOTSPOTS

What’s hot around Gage & Tollner

Live check in momentum from nearby Flynet restaurants.

Brooklyn

Today

75 check ins

54 check ins

33 check ins

29 check ins

21 check ins

All-time

73,910 check ins

67,910 check ins

33,296 check ins

27,123 check ins

25,583 check ins

NEARBY

Within walking distance

Other Blackbird spots a short walk from Gage & Tollner.

FAQ

How popular is Gage & Tollner?

Gage & Tollner has logged 6,823 check ins on Blackbird.

When is Gage & Tollner busiest?

Gage & Tollner is busiest on Sunday evenings, based on Blackbird check-in activity.

What kind of food does Gage & Tollner serve?

Gage & Tollner serves American and Steakhouse cuisine.

How expensive is Gage & Tollner?

Gage & Tollner is in the $$$$ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

How do I check in at Gage & Tollner?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Gage & Tollner in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.