Dive Bar Pizza

Name: Dive Bar Pizza
Address: 466 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

Montauk · Pizza

466 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954Directions

4.265 reviews

Diners like this bar's delicious pizza, especially the clam pie and thin, crispy options, along with their tasty wings and knots. They also highlight the friendly staff, casual atmosphere, and dog-friendly outdoor seating. Some reviews mention the staff can be unprofessional.

A rough-and-ready pizza bar with serious weekend Blackbird heat.

Dive Bar Pizza is a $ Pizza restaurant in Montauk, Montauk. It has logged 2,916 check ins on Blackbird, and is busiest Sunday midday. Check in on Blackbird when you visit.

divebarpizza.com

Why go

Dive Bar Pizza runs on casual, quick-service pizza energy: pepperoni slices, white slices, reasonable prices, and a room reviewers describe as a fun local crowd for watching the World Cup. Its Google footprint is solid rather than precious: 4.3 stars across 84 reviews.

The Blackbird data is louder. With 2,916 all-time on-chain check-ins between May 17, 2025 and August 5, 2026, this is not just a random slice stop. Sundays and Saturdays are its busiest Blackbird days, which tracks with the review picture: groups, game-watching, beach-adjacent takeout, and a proudly unfussy alternative to fancier places.

Order like the reviews do: slices if you are moving fast, or the eggplant parm if you want the full sloppy-hot-cheese commitment.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Fast facts

Dive Bar Pizza has 2,916 all-time Blackbird check-ins.
Its busiest Blackbird check-in days are Sunday and Saturday.
Google users rate it 4.3 stars from 84 reviews.
Reviewers call out pepperoni slices, white slices, fries, and eggplant parm.
Multiple highlighted reviews mention watching the World Cup here.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Did you know

Dive Bar Pizza has logged 2,916 Blackbird check-ins, with Sundays and Saturdays leading the action.

editorial/ updated 10d ago

Amenities

Features

Dine-inTakeoutDelivery

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

Open in

Check in momentum

The room in motion

Activity78

check ins · last 30 days · yesterdaycheck ins · last 30 dayslast check in · yesterday

Flynet check ins

2,916

Neighborhood

Montauk

Last 30 days

78 check ins

−69% vs prior month

Sep 28Oct 27

When it's busy

Usually not too busy right now

Tuesdaytoday

12a12p11p

Inside Dive Bar Pizza

Review signal

4.2

65 Google reviews

Google Places/ updated 10d ago

NEARBY

Within walking distance

Other Blackbird spots a short walk from Dive Bar Pizza.

FAQ

How popular is Dive Bar Pizza?

Dive Bar Pizza has logged 2,916 check ins on Blackbird.

When is Dive Bar Pizza busiest?

Dive Bar Pizza is busiest on Sunday midday, based on Blackbird check-in activity.

What kind of food does Dive Bar Pizza serve?

Dive Bar Pizza serves Pizza cuisine.

How expensive is Dive Bar Pizza?

Dive Bar Pizza is in the $ price range on a $ to $$$$ scale.

How do I check in at Dive Bar Pizza?

Download the Blackbird app, visit Dive Bar Pizza in person, and check in from the app. Check-ins earn FLY and count toward Flytown's daily Hotspots ranking.